Media loading...
"After All, Why Not? Why Shouldn't I Keep It?" features a scene from the 2001 fantasy film 'The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring.' In this meme template, the character Bilbo Baggins is depicted asking himself 'After all, why not? Why shouldn't I keep it?' This line is typically superimposed over images of everyday items that people often borrow but do not return, framing Bilbo's reluctance to surrender the One Ring in a humorous context of mundane possession-hoarding.
The line 'After all, why not? Why shouldn't I keep it?' originates from 'The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring,' which was released by New Line Cinema on December 19, 2001. In a pivotal scene, the character Bilbo Baggins, played by Ian Holm, hesitates before giving up the powerful Ring, which he is supposed to pass to his nephew Frodo. The scene encapsulates his struggle with the temptation to keep the Ring. The clip from this scene gained further recognition when uploaded by YouTuber Brian Herman on December 16, 2013. Watch the full clip here.
Origin: 2013
Also known as: after-all-why-not
See how the internet is using this meme with real viral tweet examples from X.
Spotted by AI Memes' detection system scanning X in real-time to bring you developing and trending memes on the internet.
AI Memes is a free online meme maker that lets you create viral memes with custom text, images, and AI-powered editing tools.
You can browse our growing library of popular meme templates, quickly caption images, videos, or GIFs in Caption This, or design completely custom image memes from scratch in our free-form editor with extra AI tools like Magic Prompt, Magic Face Swap, Magic Erase, and Magic Face.
The platform includes three main tools:
Text is fully customizable with font selection, weight controls, colors, and styling like outlines and italics. Each text layer has its own opacity slider, and you can drag text around the canvas or drag layers in the sidebar to control which elements appear on top. Add as many text boxes as you need with the "Add Text" button.
Upload and layer additional images onto your meme with the "Upload Image" button. Each image can be repositioned, resized, and have its opacity adjusted. Paste images directly with CMD/CTRL + V for quick edits.
Enable custom headers above your media with adjustable colors and heights—perfect for adding context or reaction text. This works in both Caption This and when editing templates from the meme library.
Yes! Use Caption This to add text, headers, and captions to videos and animated GIFs. Simply upload your video or GIF file, add your customizations, and download the finished meme. The tool preserves the animation and exports your captioned video or animated GIF ready to share.
You can also upload your own videos and animated GIFs in Caption This to add captions and text overlays. The meme template library features hundreds of popular image templates that open in the same editor with all the same customization options.
All our tools work well on mobile! Whether you're on desktop, tablet, or phone, AI Memes is fully optimized for your device. Create memes on your phone during your commute or design on your computer—the interface adapts seamlessly to your screen size. Caption This, the meme template library, and the full editor all work perfectly on touchscreens with intuitive drag-and-drop controls and mobile-friendly buttons.
Yes! There are tons of use cases to use AI Memes for outside of memes. The tools work great for any image, GIF, or video editing needs. Create tutorial screenshots with text annotations, add subtitles to explainer videos, design eye-catching YouTube thumbnails, caption product demos, build Instagram story templates, or create branded video content for your business. If you need to put text or images on media quickly, AI Memes has you covered.
AI Memes supports PNG, JPG, and WEBP images, MP4 videos, and animated GIFs. Your download will match your upload format—bring us an image, get an image back; bring us a video, get a video back; bring us a GIF, get a GIF back.
No account required! You can start creating memes immediately without signing up. Simply visit any tool, upload or select a template, customize it, and download. However, creating a free account gives you access to features like saved projects and your meme creation history. Upgrading to AI Memes Pro removes the AI Memes watermark from your downloads and unlocks tons of powerful AI features in the full editor.
